I still remember opening my first baby doll for Christmas and thinking how wonderful that new plastic smell was. Now when I smell the aroma of fresh PVC off-gassing, I’m struck with a new thought, “Eeewww, smells like poison!”
The Center for Health, Environment and Justice (CHEJ) released a new study, “Volatile Vinyl: The New Shower Curtain’s Chemical Smell,” in which they reveal that PVC shower curtains can release over 100 toxic chemicals.
The truth about PVC is even more shocking than we ever imagined. The chemicals researched in the study have been associated with developmental damage, as well as damage to the liver, central nervous, respiratory and reproductive systems. It amazed me to learn that some chemicals were found in the air a full 28 days after a PVC shower curtain was unwrapped and hung!
The study also found many more unsettling facts about PVC shower curtains:
- Contain high levels of phthalates
- Contain high levels of volatile organic compounds (VOC’s)
- Contain high levels of organotins
- Contain lead, cadmium and other metals
- Heat and humidity can increase the release of these chemicals
There is some good news in all of this mess. CHEJ confirmed that many leading retailers of PVC shower curtains have plans to phase them out. The list includes: Bed Bath and Beyond, IKEA, JC Penney, Macy’s, Marks and Spencer, Sears/Kmart and Target.
Thanks to CHEJ for their ongoing work to protect our families with well-documented research and education projects. You can read the full report at their website.
UPDATE 6/18/08:
Q: Is there a safe alternative?
A: Yes. EVA is a non-toxic alternative used in some shower curtains. There is a growing trend to replace PVC with EVA, so it won’t be difficult to find a substitution.
Watch for a follow-up article on EVA soon!
Filed under: Buzz, PVC, Phthalates, Toxic Chemical Research | Tagged: CHEJ, EVA, Off-gassing, PVC, Toxic Shower Curtains
Wow! I never thought about the other forms of plastic that we do not eat from!
I had a horrific time with the smell from a clear plastic table cloth I bought to protect my pretty table cloth from spills. The odor was so strong I could barely stand to unfold it, and it lasted for nearly a week.
I think I need to toss it!
I really feel like throwing out everything I have that’s made of plastic…even the ones that haven’t been in the news yet. It’s probably only a matter of time.
OK, so here’s my question: I have a cloth shower curtain and a plastic liner, but I’m not sure what it’s made of; it is some sort of plastic, though. Once I throw that out, what kind of liner should I use? Is there a safe alternative yet?
Kim, I second that. Where can we currently buy a safe plastic shower liner?
Hi Kim and Kirstin,
There are many great PVC substitutions made from non-toxic EVA (please see our updated note on the blog post).
Alicia
Ah, thanks!
Would you have to lick the shower curtain to get exposed to the phalates? How likely is it that beyond that initial smell (ours is gone already) that the negative chemicals are still there? Just curious. Thanks!
Now that all this new information is coming out about PVC, I wonder about all the PVC plumbing that has been put in our homes. Is this a problem that will need to be fixed? Is it a problem to cook with water that runs through PVC plumbing??? Has any research been done on this yet? Yikes!
Ikea shower curtains are PVC free!! And just over a buck. Yay!
[...] join with Mike Schade to hit this issue head on. They’ve taken the confusion surrounding PVC and replaced it with [...]
What about plastic garbage bags? I can smell that “plasticy” smell every time I take one out of the box to put it into my kitchen garbage can. . .I’m guessing that those would leave toxins floating in the air in your home also??
I contacted Prestige Toy company, which makes toys for Carter’s and asked if their three pack of little squirty bath toys are made with BPA, PVC, phthalates, etc. They responded that they are made with a phthalate free PVC. What is this and even if PVC is phthalate free, doesn’t it still contain tons of other harmful toxins?
[...] SAF Baby Debuts Guide to PVC-Free Baby Dolls Just in Time for Christmas Posted on November 2, 2008 by softlanding Parents are winding up for Christmas shopping and many have committed to buying PVC-free toys this season. We’ve been looking ourselves, and it’s no easy task. Thank goodness the Mom’s of SAF Baby have accepted the challenge!The big question is, “Isn’t phthalate-free PVC/Vinyl good enough?” And the simple answer is NO. Locating baby dolls free of phthalates has proven easier than finding PVC-free options. We’ve discussed several reasons for avoiding PVC before: [...]
[...] CURIOUS about why it’s important to avoid PVC? Learn more here. [...]
[...] CURIOUS about why it’s important to avoid PVC? Learn more here. [...]
I had an unopened plastic lace tablecloth that I purchased many years ago which I thought would be very pretty for a Christmas boutique. I placed it on my table and had to sit for six hours smelling the horrible rubber like-odor coming from the tablecloth.
[...] Read more about why it’s important to avoid PVC, whether phthalate-free or not. Possibly related posts: [...]
[...] more about having PVC, phthalate and lead-free products in our homes. As we’ve mentioned before, PVC’s entire life cycle – from production through use and disposal – has a negative impact [...]